2000 Lavinia Byrne

Lavinia Byrne (born 1947 in Birmingham) is a former nun who in 2000 left the Institute of the Blessed Virgin Mary after 35 years as a member, a teacher at the Cambridge Theological Federation and a regular on BBC Radio 4’s Thought for the Day .  Her 1993 book Woman at the Altar  outlined her arguments for women priests, and she also wrote about contraception.   Despite her criticism of the Vatican’s treatment, she spoke out positively about Pope John Paul II  after his death.

As an eminent Catholic nun she resigned from her order he Institute of the Blessed Virgin Mary , saying the Vatican has been “bullying” her to abandon support for women priests.   She said she had a “dilemma of conscience” after asked by senior figures at the Vatican to state publicly that only men should be ordained as priests.
“I remain a loyal and committed member of the Roman Catholic Church,” she said. “My quarrel is not with the Catholic church in this country but with…Rome”. “They are using techniques that seem to belong to another age. They are behaving like the Inquisition. I feel bullied.”

Her  book Women at the Altar, set out arguments for women priests, it was condemned by the Vatican when it came out 1993 and its distribution banned, she says.   She has also argued in favour of contraception for married Catholics.  Vatican figures subsequently called on her to declare her opposition to women priests and back the Catholic church’s stance against artificial birth control.

‘Deeply sad’

She said she finally decided had no choice but to leave the religious order she joined at the age of 17.
I am deeply sad to have to leave a religious congregation which has a splendid record of championing the place of women in the church and do so with great regret,” she said.   “Women do some of the most bold and adventurous work in the church the world over, working with the poor, needy and disadvantaged as well as in universities, hospitals and schools“. “It is too easy to make them a sitting target by questioning their integrity and undermining their commitment to the Gospel.
(I wrote the book) in total good faith at a time when discussion about women priests was the subject of open debate, especially in the UK.”

Audio of Speech by Lavinia Byrne

To listen to the audio of the speech click (or double click) the play button  in the box below